YONGE NAWE
ENVIRONMENTAL ACTION GROUP
Yonge Nawe Environmental Action Group
Supporting communities through environmental action
Home

About Yonge Nawe

Programmes

Resources

Press Information

Membership

Links

Search

Contact Us

The People have Spoken. Now Listen and Act!!!

On the 27th March 2003, Education Minister John Carmichael led a highly emotional delegation of interested and affected parties at an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Scoping meeting to oppose the proposed Chipping Plant and Pulp Mill within the premises of the Swazi Paper Mills near Matsapha industrial sites.
 

A side view  of Swazi Paper Mills in Matsapha Industrial Sites
Minister Carmichael and approximately forty other interested and affected parties strongly objected the proposed development arguing that the proposed development would have an adverse and extremely serious environmental impact 
on an area that they already consider to be an environmental disaster. "The levels of pollution and contamination have reached such critical and alarming proportions that we strongly urge His Majesty’s Government to declare the Swazi Paper Mills vicinity and surrounding areas as an area that should be given the highest priority for environmental rehabilitation," lamented the Minister. 

Effluet from a nearby Paper Millr released into the Lushushwana  river
In the last quarter of 2002, there were reports that the Lushushwana River, which runs along the Swazi Paper Mills, was highly contaminated and residents suspected the company as responsible. Members of the Masundviwini and Hlambeni communities alleged that their domestic water was polluted as a result of Swazi Paper Mills. "Swazi Paper Mills has been releasing effluents into the Lushushwana
 River and our domestic water is now contaminated," Siboniso Gumbi, a community representative said. "There is no longer any aquatic life in the river and communities are prone to water borne diseases such as cholera," he added. Interested and affected parties spoke in a uniform voice that Swazi Paper Mills should start by addressing the myriad of concerns raised under the existing paper mill before looking into the proposed project.

Interested and affected objected the proposed chipping plant and pulp mill citing various reasons which include among others:

  • Air pollution
The high levels of sulphur dioxide and methyl mecaptans will have a negative impact on the health of communities. This will give rise to high incidences of respiratory ailments
  • Water pollution
There is no guarantee that the plant will release effluent into the Lushushwana River that will meet environmental standards. 
  • Air Traffic
The emissions from burning fossil fuels will adversely reduce visibility around surrounding areas and disrupt aviation traffic. This can cause catastrophic accidents for the nearby communities.
  • Road Traffic 
The haulage of the raw materials will result in an increase in heavy traffic and congestion.
  • Tourism potential
The proposed development will adversely affect tourism in the area. Exclusive Resorts (PTY) has been granted a Casino License to operate adjacent to the proposed mill. 
  •  Dumping of Solid Waste
The proposed development would dump its solid wastes at the Matsapha dumpsite. This facility does not meet the requirements of the Swaziland Environmental Authority Act and the Waste Regulations of 2000. The poor location and management of this site is currently causing untold health problems for the Matsapha community and surrounding areas.
  • Residential Development
The proposed chipping and pulp mill is serious threat and undermines the development of residential development adjacent to the site, namely Nokwane Township.

According to Swazi Paper Mills Group Environmental Officer Almarie Stamp, the proposed pulp mill will employ more than 100 people. She stated that the proposed development represents a significant investment and development in the area. The minister said "The time has come for us to weigh the benefit of job creation as opposed to the negative impact of pollution on the environment and the health of the people. While encouraging new investments, it is essential to look at potential environmental threats that the project may pose." "This proposed industry pollutes the total environment, he added. Meanwhile, 
Mr Siboniso Gumbi said that the existing paper mill has no regard for human life and the quality of life of the community. 

Paper effluent dumped adjacent to the mill

"A community poultry project had to be shut down because health inspectors found the water too contaminated and resulted in chickens dying," Gumbi said. A local farmer stated that his cattle were dying as a result of contaminated water. " When I slaughter my beasts, I find a thick layer of paper fibre in their stomach 
and this comes from the effluent Swazi Paper Mills releases in the river, he said." "The people have spoken! As a 'watchdog' organisation we will be monitoring the process and ensure that the Swaziland Environmental Authority takes these submissions seriously," stated Mr. Samuel Payne, Campaigns Coordinator of Yonge Nawe. 

"We now have the Environmental Management Act of 2002 that provides rights and responsibilities of interested and affected parties. This provides a clear framework for environmental injustices not to occur," he added.

Poor quality of drinking water and air pollution is a problem that Swaziland needs to give high priority. Yonge Nawe is encouraging the public to participate in EIA Scoping processes. 

Will this development be opposed or will politics rear its ugly head? Send your comments or views to Yonge Nawe. 


Yonge Nawe
Yonge Nawe
Environmental Action Group
Email: yonawe@realnet.co.sz
P O Box 2061
Mbabane
Swaziland
Tel: +268 404 7701
         +268 404 1394
Fax: +268 404 7701